Letter XXVI.
The Lunatic Asylum at Hanwell.
London, July 28, 1845.
Since we came to England we have visited the Lunatic Asylum at
Hanwell, in the neighborhood of London. It is a large building, divided
into numerous apartments, with the plainest accommodations, for the
insane poor of the county of Middlesex. It is superintended by Dr.
Conolly, who is most admirably fitted for the place he fills, by his
great humanity, sagacity, and ingenuity.
I put these qualities together as necessary to each other. Mere
humanity, without tact and skill, would fail deplorably. The rude and
coarse methods of government which consist in severity, are the most
obvious ones; they suggest themselves to the dullest minds, and cost
nothing but bodily strength to put them in execution; the gentler
methods require reflection, knowledge, and dexterity. It is these which
Dr. Conolly applies with perfect success. He has taken great pains to
make himself acquainted, by personal observation, with the treatment of
the insane in different hospitals, not only in England, but on the
continent. He found that to be the most efficacious which interferes
least with their personal liberty, and on this principle, the truth of
which an experience of several years has now confirmed, he founded the
system of treatment at Hanwell.
We had letters to Dr. Conolly, with the kindness and gentleness of
whose manners we were much struck. He conducted us over the several
wards of the Asylum. We found in it a thousand persons of both sexes,
not one of whom was in seclusion, that is to say confined because it was
dangerous to allow him to go at large; nor were they subjected to any
apparent restraint whatever. Some were engaged in reading, some in
exercises and games of skill; of the females some were occupied in
sewing, others at work in the kitchen or the laundry; melancholic
patients were walking about in silence or sitting gloomily by
themselves; idiots were rocking their bodies backward and forward as
they sat, but all were peaceable in their demeanor, and the greatest
quiet prevailed. No chastisement of any kind is inflicted; the lunatic
is always treated as a patient, and never as an offender. When he
becomes so outrageous and violent that his presence can be endured no
longer, he is put into a room with padded walls and floors where he can
do himself no mischief, and where his rage is allowed to exhale. Even
the straight jacket is unknown here.
I said that the demeanor of all the patients with whom the Asylum was
swarming was peaceable. There was one exception. On entering one of the
wards, a girl of an earnest and determined aspect, as soon as she saw
Dr. Conolly began to scream violently, and sprang towards him, thrusting
aside the bystanders by main force. Two of the female attendants came
immediately up and strove to appease her, holding her back without
severity, as a mother would restrain her infant. I saw them struggling
with her for some time; how they finally disposed of her I did not
observe, but her screams had ceased before we left the ward.
Among the patients was one who, we were told, was remarkable for his
extravagant love of finery, and whose cell was plastered over with
glaring colored prints and patches of colored paper ornamentally
disposed. He wore on his hat a broad strip of tarnished lace, and had
decorated his waistcoat with several perpendicular rows of pearl
buttons.
"You have made your room very fine here," said the doctor.
"Yes," said he, smiling and evidently delighted, "but, my dear sir,
all is vanity--all is vanity, sir, and vexation of spirit. There is but
one thing that we ought to strive for, and that is the kingdom of
heaven."
As there was no disputing this proposition, we passed on to another
cell, at the door of which stood a tall, erect personage, who was busy
with a pot of paint and a brush, inscribing the pannels with mottoes and
scraps of verse. The walls of his room were covered with poetry and
pithy sentences. Some of the latter appeared to be of his own
composition, and, were not badly turned; their purport generally was
this: that birth is but a trivial accident, and that virtue and talent
are the only true nobility. This man was found wandering about in
Chiswick, full of a plan for educating the Prince of Wales in a manner
to enable him to fill the throne with credit and usefulness. As his name
could not be learned, the appellation of "Chiswick" was given him, which
he had himself adopted, styling himself Mr. "Chiswick" in his mottoes,
but always taking care to put the name between inverted commas.
As we proceeded, a man rose from his seat, and laying both hands on a
table before him, so as to display his fingers, ornamented with rings
made of black ribbon, in which glass buttons were set for jewels,
addressed Dr. Conolly with great respect, formally setting forth that he
was in great want of a new coat for Sundays, the one he had on being
positively unfit to appear in, and that a better had been promised him.
The doctor stopped, inquired into the case, and the poor fellow was
gratified by the assurance that the promised coat should be speedily
forthcoming.
In his progress through the wards Dr. Conolly listened with great
patience to the various complaints of the inmates. One of them came up
and told us that he did not think the methods of the institution
judicious. "The patients," said he, "are many of them growing worse. One
in particular, who has been here for several weeks, I can see is growing
worse every day." Dr. Conolly asked the name of this patient--"I can not
tell," said the man, "but I can bring him to you." "Bring him then,"
said the doctor; and after a moment's absence he returned, leading up
one of the healthiest and quietest looking men in the ward. "He looks
better to be sure," said the man, "but he is really worse." A burst of
laughter from the patients who stood by followed this saying, and one of
them looking at me knowingly, touched his forehead to intimate that the
objector was not exactly in his senses.
In one of the female wards we were introduced, as gentlemen from
America, to a respectable-looking old lady in black, who sat with a
crutch by her side. "Are you not lawyers?" she asked, and when we
assured her that we were only Yankees, she rebuked us mildly for
assuming such a disguise, when she knew very well that we were a couple
of attorneys. "And you, doctor," she added, "I am surprised that you
should have any thing to do with such a deception." The doctor answered
that he was very sorry she had so bad an opinion of him, as she must be
sensible that he had never said any thing to her which was not true.
"Ah, doctor," she rejoined, "but you are the dupe of these people."
It was in the same ward, I think, that a well-dressed woman, in a
bonnet and shawl, was promenading the room, carrying a bible and two
smaller volumes, apparently prayer or hymn books. "Have you heard the
very reverend Mr. ----, in ---- chapel?" she asked of my
fellow-traveller. I have unfortunately forgotten the name of the
preacher and his chapel. On being answered in the negative, "Then go and
hear him," she added, "when you return to London." She went on to say
that the second coming of the Saviour was to take place, and the world
to be destroyed in a very few days, and that she had a commission to
proclaim the approach of that event. "These poor people," said she,
"think that I am here on the same account as themselves, when I am only
here to prepare the way for the second coming."
"I'm thinking, please yer honor, that it is quite time I was let out
of this place," said a voice as we entered one of the wards. Dr. Conolly
told me that he had several Irish patients in the asylum, and that they
gave him the most trouble on account of the hurry in which they were to
be discharged. We heard the same request eagerly made in the same brogue
by various other patients of both sexes.
As I left this multitude of lunatics, promiscuously gathered from the
poor and the reduced class, comprising all varieties of mental disease,
from idiocy to madness, yet all of them held in such admirable order by
the law of kindness, that to the casual observer most of them betrayed
no symptoms of insanity, and of the rest, many appeared to be only very
odd people, quietly pursuing their own harmless whims, I could not but
feel the highest veneration for the enlightened humanity by which the
establishment was directed. I considered, also, if the feeling of
personal liberty, the absence of physical restraint, and the power of
moral motives, had such power to hold together in perfect peace and
order, even a promiscuous band of lunatics, how much greater must be
their influence over the minds of men in a state of sanity, and on how
false a foundation rest all the governments of force! The true basis of
human polity, appointed by God in our nature, is the power of moral
motives, which is but another term for public opinion.
Of the political controversies which at present agitate the country,
the corn-law question is that which calls forth the most feeling; I mean
on the part of those who oppose the restrictions on the introduction of
foreign grain--for, on the other side, it appears to me that the battle
is languidly fought. Nothing can exceed the enthusiasm of the
adversaries of the corn-laws. With some of them the repeal of the tax on
bread is the remedy for all political evils. "Free trade, free trade,"
is the burden of their conversation, and although a friend of free trade
myself, to the last and uttermost limit, I have been in circles in
England, in which I had a little too much of it. Yet this is an example
to prove what a strong hold the question has taken of the minds of men,
and how completely the thoughts of many are absorbed by it. Against such
a feeling as that which has been kindled in Great Britain, on the
corn-law question, no law in our country could stand. So far as I can
judge, it is spreading, as well as growing stronger. I am told that many
of the farmers have become proselytes of the League. The League is a
powerful and prodigiously numerous association, with ample and
increasing funds, publishing able tracts, supporting well-conducted
journals, and holding crowded public meetings, which are addressed by
some of the ablest speakers in the United Kingdom. I attended one of
these at Covent Garden. Stage, pit, boxes, and gallery of that large
building were filled with one of the most respectable-looking audiences,
men and women, I have ever seen. Among the speakers of the evening were
Cobden and Fox. Cobden in physiognomy and appearance might almost pass
for an American, and has a certain New England sharpness and shrewdness
in his way of dealing with a subject. His address was argumentative, yet
there was a certain popular clearness about it, a fertility of familiar
illustration, and an earnest feeling, which made it uncommonly
impressive. Fox is one of the most fluent and ingenious speakers I ever
heard in a popular assembly. Both were listened to by an audience which
seemed to hang on every word that fell from their lips.
The musical world here are talking about Colman's improvement in the
piano. I have seen the instrument which the inventor brought out from
America. It is furnished with a row of brass reeds, like those of the
instrument called the Seraphine. These take up the sound made by the
string of the piano, and prolong it to any degree which is desired. It
is a splicing of the sounds of one instrument upon another. Yet if the
invention were to be left where it is, in Colman's instrument, it could
not succeed with the public. The notes of the reeds are too harsh and
nasal, and want the sweetness and mellowness of tone which belong to the
string of the piano.
At present the invention is in the hands of Mr. Rand, the portrait
painter, a countryman of ours, who is one of the most ingenious
mechanicians in the world. He has improved the tones of the reeds till
they rival, in softness and fullness, those of the strings, and, in
fact, can hardly be distinguished from them, so that the sounds of the
two instruments run into one another without any apparent difference.
Mr. Rand has contrived three or four different machines for making the
reeds with dispatch and precision; and if the difficulty of keeping the
strings, which are undergoing a constant relaxation, in perfect unison
with the reeds can be overcome, I see nothing to prevent the most
complete and brilliant success.